Hi. I am researching healthy options for the plates and bowls that my young children eat off of. They are too young to eat off of glass, china or pottery due to the risk of breakage. I have come accross numerous non chemical leaching solutions for baby bottles and sippy cups...yet I have found no healthy alternatives for the plates and bowls they eat off of. Everything seems to be made of plastic and it's difficult to know which are ok and which aren't. In general, is "melamine" considered a safe option? I would welcome any suggestions or brands that are safe. Thank You.
Comments (6)
1. 01/15/2008 04:24:27 PM
The main problem that we have found with plastic plates and bowls is that if they are painted, the paint may contain lead. That's especially true for plates made in China. So the best choice might be to pick unpainted plates or bowls, or avoid ones made in China. In general, polycarbonate plastic (the kind that contains the endocrine disrupting chemical bisphenol A) is clear, so if you’re in doubt and there's no recycling symbol #7 to clue you in, then it's safest to avoid the clear plastic bowls. That pretty much leaves you with opaque, unpainted plastic tableware.
Another option is to look for unlined stainless steel plates and bowls rather than plastic. Camping stores often have a good selection of stainless steel dishware. Wooden plates and bowls are another good choice, though if they are imported and coated with a hard glossy finish it might be a safest to swab them to make sure there's no lead in the finish.
Plastic ware is sometimes labeled with a recycling logo and a number. In general, HDPE plastic, identified by the number 2 on the bottom of the cup or dish, or polypropylene, number 5, are the best and are recyclable. Melamine is a nitrogen-containing chemical that is used as a fire retardant and when combined with formaldehyde forms a resin.
No matter what type of plastic you choose, bacteria can grow in scratches and cracks so be sure to recycle or throw out bowls once they start to look worn.
2. 01/23/2008 05:16:52 PM
Is melamine safe to eat off of?
3. 01/29/2008 10:23:40 AM
Melamine won't release BPA. It's a totally different kind of 'plastic'. Melamine is a nitrogen-containing chemical that is used as a fire retardant and when combined with formaldehyde forms a resin. Melamine products are not known to release formaldehyde gases. Like other plastics, bacteria can grow in scratches and cracks and dishes should be thrown out when they show signs of wear. You'll have to toss it in the trash, you can't recycle melamine.
4. 02/15/2008 01:45:50 PM
Dr. Gina,
Melamine is recyclable. At least, food safe melamine is recyclable as it is made primarily from organic materials.
Food safe melamine is made from 40-60% wood flour, which is 100% waste by product from the paper mills. Melamine components can currently be 100% recycled and used as sandblasting substrate.
I hope this information is helpful. The government keeps watch on envoirnmentally friendly and green items, and this actually falls in that arena. By all means, encourage your readers to recycle these items, and not just toss them in the trash bin!
5. 06/11/2008 04:23:55 PM
On the melamine topic, i have some melamine plastic plates that do have the #7 recycle symbol. Why would they say melamine AND #7?
6. 06/17/2008 11:23:23 AM
The numbers on plastics are intended to aid recycling by identifying the type of plastic. A number 7 means “other” and identifies it as a plastic, like polycarbonate, that usually can’t be recycled. Most, but not all, plastic labeled with a 7 is polycarbonate (which leaches BPA) but it does include other plastics, like melamine or even new bio-based plastics. Unfortunately, there’s not an easy way for consumers to know what type of plastic they have when it’s marked with a 7. Check the packaging, the company website and even try emailing the company if you want to know whether a plastic marked 7 is polycarbonate. For more on plastics, you may want to check out this info on plastics and BPA.